Judge imposes $12,500 in sanctions on three federal officials after failed ICE release order
Magistrate Judge Maureen Kelly held the Attorney General, the DHS Secretary, and the acting ICE field office director in civil contempt for disregarding court orders regarding the release of a Salvadoran immigrant.
By Nathan Cooper ·

U.S. Magistrate Judge Maureen Kelly imposed a $12,500 sanction on three top federal officials this week for failing to comply with a court order to release a detained immigrant. The sanctions require U.S. Attorney General Todd Blanche, Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin, and John E. Rife, the acting ICE field office director for enforcement and removal operations, to pay attorney fees and costs. Kelly issued the ruling in the Western District of Pennsylvania, where she presides over immigration cases.
The dispute centers on Nain Vasquez Gonzalez, an El Salvadoran citizen who entered the United States in 2016 as a minor. Gonzalez was detained by immigration officials in January 2023 following a drug possession arrest. He remained in custody at the Moshannon Valley Processing Center in Clearfield County for 38 months. In an April 28 decision, Kelly ruled that the length of his detention violated due process and ordered his immediate release. That release occurred later the same day.
On June 26, agents from U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement rearrested Gonzalez during a nationwide surge enforcement action. Court records indicate he was waiting for a bus in Fairview, New Jersey, around 8:20 a.m. when four agents in two vehicles approached him. They asked if he was Fernando Daniel. When Gonzalez said no and stated he had a release order in his wallet, the agents did not check the document. He was held for 11 hours before his attorney filed a motion for his release.
Kelly ordered the government to identify the officers involved and provide body camera footage. The officials provided inconsistent accounts and failed to produce the specific video of Gonzalez being taken into custody. By the deadline, ICE identified one arresting officer but claimed his camera was not charged. The government described this as a preventable error but argued it did not show bad faith. When Kelly requested footage from other agents, the government asked to file it under seal. She denied the request and criticized the use of masks to hide agent identities.
ICE eventually submitted video from five agents, none of which showed Gonzalez being arrested. At least 15 agents were working to arrest 20 people at the time. Kelly described the government's effort to comply with her orders as involving inconsistent stories and dubious excuses. She stated the officials either willfully attempted to obfuscate the circumstances or were unable to maintain proper records. She called ICE's practice of hiding agent identities deeply troubling and un-American.
Robert Jackel of Legal Services of New Jersey, who represents Gonzalez, argued that the officials' changing stories and failure to produce footage were implausible. He noted that the District of New Jersey had issued multiple warnings to ICE regarding similar violations. Jackel said sanctions were necessary to prevent future conduct. The government responded that the failure to answer the court resulted from a scramble to provide answers after making a mistake. Assistant U.S. Attorney Heidi Grogan wrote that the agency released Gonzalez as soon as they realized the error.
Kelly found the government's declarations, made under oath by people not present at the arrest, to be disconcerting. She noted that these declarations contained factual conclusions and potentially undercuts the credibility of future testimony. She warned that at worst, the conduct could be considered perjury. The judge emphasized that the government must adhere to court orders with the same rigor as any other litigant.
Immigration experts described the ruling as unusual but appropriate for maintaining court authority. Adrian Roe, a Pittsburgh immigration attorney, said the court treated the government like any other party not in compliance with an order. Vanessa Stine, a senior staff attorney for the ACLU of Pennsylvania, called ICE's actions part of a larger pattern of indiscriminate stops. The Department of Justice did not return a message seeking comment, and the U.S. Attorney's Office in Pittsburgh declined to comment.






