90 Days: The Critical Window for New Haven Injury Claims
Insurance carriers in New Haven are denying injury claims based on five specific legal arguments, ranging from shared fault to missed municipal notice deadlines.
By Mei Chen ·

New Haven residents facing injury claim denials are often told their written notice arrived too late. Under Section 13a-149 of Connecticut law, individuals must notify a town or city within 90 days of a road or sidewalk injury. A 2025 Appellate Court decision sided with New Haven in a case where a woman injured in the Pitkin Street Tunnel could not prove the clerk’s office received her notice. This deadline is the first hurdle many claimants encounter when dealing with municipal liability.
Beyond timing, carriers frequently argue that the injured party shares blame for the incident. General Statutes § 52-572h mandates that payments be reduced to match the claimant's percentage of fault. If the claimant's share exceeds the combined share of those being sued, they receive nothing. Adjusters rarely explain how these percentages are calculated. Personal injury attorneys in New Haven often collect photos, witness names, and store video to challenge these numbers and lower the assigned fault share.
Property owners' insurers also deny claims by asserting the owner did not know about the hazard. Federal court rulings require proof that the owner knew of the specific problem or would have found it with a basic check. In winter, carriers invoke the ongoing storm rule, claiming owners had reasonable time to clear ice after a storm. Lawyers counter this by requesting inspection records, cleaning schedules, and weather reports to demonstrate how long the hazard persisted.
Carriers frequently blame prior medical conditions for current pain. Claims adjusters review medical histories to identify old injuries, such as back problems, to justify lower payouts. Attorneys address this by having doctors compare the patient's condition before and after the incident. These notes clarify what pre-existed and what the new injury added to the patient's health status.
Gaps in treatment also trigger denials. Carriers point to the time between the incident and the first doctor visit to argue the injury was not serious. The Mayo Clinic notes that whiplash symptoms often appear days after an injury. Lawyers gather urgent care notes, pharmacy receipts, and messages to employers to document when symptoms started and why treatment was delayed.
The statute of limitations for these cases is two years from the date of injury or when the injury was discovered, per Section 52-584. The outside limit is three years from the act that caused the harm. Legal experts recommend sending notice via certified mail to keep proof of arrival and marking all deadlines on a calendar. Starting the process early allows time to correct procedural errors.
Residents who receive a denial letter should read it to identify the exact reason for rejection. They should request written proof from the insurance company and continue all medical appointments. Keeping records and writing down key dates is essential, especially for claims involving city infrastructure. If the stated reason does not match the facts, a Connecticut lawyer should review the file before the claimant responds.






