Five states pass noncitizen voting bans with support above 60 percent
Ballot measures in Kansas, Alaska, Arkansas, South Dakota, and West Virginia codify citizenship requirements for state and local elections, while a related proposal in California was rejected.
By Nathan Cooper ·

Voters in five states approved measures barring noncitizens from voting in state and local races.
The initiatives passed in Kansas, Alaska, Arkansas, South Dakota, and West Virginia. Each measure secured support levels exceeding 60 percent. These state actions clarify or codify citizenship requirements despite existing federal law prohibiting noncitizens from voting in federal elections.
Jason Snead, executive director of the Honest Elections Project, described the results as evidence of bipartisan support for citizenship verification. He cited a 2024 Gallup poll finding that 83 percent of Americans support requiring first-time voters to provide proof of citizenship. The survey indicated that 66 percent of Democrats also favor the requirement.
These state victories align with the political agenda of President Donald Trump and congressional Republicans. The Supreme Court is preparing to review a dispute in Arizona. The case will determine whether a state can require proof of citizenship on voter registration forms and remove suspected noncitizens from rolls before an election.
Not all related measures succeeded. California voters defeated Proposition 39 by roughly 17 percentage points. The measure, which would have required voter ID and additional citizenship verification, received 58.5 percent of the vote against it and 41.4 percent in favor. Snead attributed the defeat to the political environment in California and noted that the opposition campaign raised more than $30 million. An Arizona proposal also failed, which Snead said included broader provisions beyond noncitizen voting.
The state actions follow failed efforts in Congress to pass the SAVE America Act. Senate Majority Leader John Thune stated that Republicans lacked the votes to pass the bill. Democrats argued the legislation would disenfranchise eligible voters. The bill became a flashpoint during a Department of Homeland Security shutdown, as Trump’s administration tied the bill to department funding.
Hans von Spakovsky, a former member of the Federal Election Commission, criticized the Democratic Party for politicizing what he called a 90-10 issue. He warned that the new state provisions may be ineffective unless states can verify voters’ citizenship. The upcoming Supreme Court case, Republican National Committee v. Mi Familia Vota, will decide if federal law prevents Arizona from requiring documentary proof of citizenship.
Snead pointed to recent Justice Department arrests and a failure in New Jersey’s automatic voter registration system as examples of the current system’s weaknesses. The New Jersey system added 6,600 noncitizens to the rolls, with almost 400 of them voting. Spakovsky noted that a ruling in favor of Arizona would apply only to future registrations. He expressed concern that Democrats might defund the SAVE database at the Department of Homeland Security to prevent states from checking the citizenship of already registered voters.
More Business · National news · Consumer Watch · Report a business · Got a Story?






