AdvertiseDonate
Saturday, November 21, 2026Local news for Bradenton and Florida.
Bradenton Gazette · 4916 26th Street West, Suite 100, Bradenton, FL 34207
News · Dublin

ECHR Sanction: Romanian Lawyer Banned for Two Years After Citing Fake Cases

The European Court of Human Rights found that a legal representative failed to verify AI-generated citations, causing significant delays in judicial proceedings.

By Mei Chen ·

Illustration for: ECHR Sanction: Romanian Lawyer Banned for Two Years After Citing Fake Cases
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

A Romanian lawyer will be barred from representing clients before the European Court of Human Rights for a period of two years. The penalty stems from her failure to properly verify case law citations generated by artificial intelligence tools. Court President Mattias Guyomar approved a proposal from a judicial chamber to impose the exclusion on Thursday.

The chamber determined that the lawyer’s written observations contained numerous errors regarding the court's case law. The mistakes included references to cases that did not exist, often described as hallucinated by AI systems. The submissions also cited fictitious paragraphs from genuine judgments and relied on existing case law that contradicted the arguments being advanced or was irrelevant to the specific legal issues.

The lawyer acknowledged using AI tools to draft the documents. She characterized the mistakes as inaccuracies and citation errors. However, the chamber concluded that the issues represented a pattern of repeated substantive errors rather than isolated slips. The panel found that her conduct fell short of the professional and ethical duties required by the court and Romanian domestic law.

Under the Legal Profession Act and relevant case law, lawyers must act as reasonably competent professionals. The chamber stated that the lawyer had a duty to independently check all AI-generated references against authoritative sources, such as the court's case-law database, before filing. The panel viewed her admission that she had not sufficiently checked all cited case law as an understatement of the problem.

The review process included comments from the lawyer, the Romanian government, and the Romanian National Bar Association. The chamber noted that many errors were repetitive and would have been detectable through a cursory check of the database. The lack of verification meant the court spent considerable time verifying the observations and initiating proceedings under the rules. This additional work was deemed incompatible with the court's functions under the European Convention on Human Rights.

The decision meets the threshold of exceptional circumstances required to exclude an advocate from representing a party before the court. The exclusion does not prevent the lawyer from having her rights of representation restored in the future. In the specific case that triggered the review, the applicant had two representatives. The second representative will continue to assist the party, ensuring the litigation proceeds without interruption.

More News · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Bradenton Gazette in your inboxLocal news for Bradenton and Florida. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Get Bradenton Gazette in your inboxLocal news for Bradenton and Florida. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.